EASTERN STAR REAL ESTATE PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: ESTAR🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2025

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

the company continuously emphasizes its internal control system. The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to evaluate and review the internal control system, focusing on ensuring that the internal control system is adequate and appropriate for business operations, promoting efficiency and effectiveness in operations, and ensuring efficient, economical, and valuable use of resources, which includes asset protection, prevention or reduction of errors, damages, leakages, waste, or fraud. Furthermore, internal and external financial reports must be accurate, reliable, and timely, and operations must comply with the company's rules and policies established for operational control. In this regard, the company has engaged external parties as internal auditors (Outsourcing) to audit the operations within the company and its subsidiaries to ensure compliance with the company's rules and policies. The internal auditors will conduct audits according to the annual internal audit plan. 2025 approved by the Audit Committee, taking into account the results of potential risk assessments and the adequacy assessment of the internal control system for key operational systems, following the guidelines of COSO and the Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand, as well as the guidelines of the Stock Exchange of Thailand. This is to provide recommendations for corrective actions based on identified observations for management's consideration and implementation. Quarterly, the internal auditors will compile various operational deficiencies and report them directly to the Audit Committee for acknowledgment and to direct management to implement further improvements.
Furthermore, during the year,
2025 The company has established an internal audit unit and internal audit executives who are independent and report directly to the Audit Committee. Their role is to review the operations of various key departments within the scope of work assigned and approved by the Audit Committee, and to report the results to the Audit Committee to ensure that business operations achieve their objectives and goals, reduce potential losses, and coordinate and collaborate with external internal auditors.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

In 2025, the Audit Committee assessed the company's internal control system by reviewing and inquiring information from management and internal auditors. The conclusion was that the company's internal control system, across its five components—Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control Activities, Information and Communication, and Monitoring Activities—is adequate and appropriate, with details as follows:

1. Control Environment

The company has environmental factors that promote an adequate and appropriate internal control environment, with various management aspects contributing to the effectiveness of internal control, as follows:

1.1 Written policies and procedures have been established regarding good corporate governance and ethical standards and business conduct.

1.2 The vision, mission, and objectives are clearly defined annually, taking into account various factors such as economic conditions, market conditions, and competitive landscape. Clear performance measurement standards are also established to guide operations and monitor performance towards achieving goals. These are regularly reviewed to align with the constantly changing current situation.

1.3 The organizational structure and segregation of duties for each department are clearly defined. Additionally, operational manuals for key departments are clearly prepared, and sub-systems are improved for efficiency to enhance work flexibility, ensure thoroughness, reduce redundant tasks, and ensure all parties operate under the same standards.
1.4 A personal data protection policy has been established for the collection and disclosure of personal data, and rights to access personal data have been defined, in compliance with the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562 (2019). A Personal Data Control Working Group has also been appointed to safeguard the personal data received by the company and to ensure that the company's personal data, including its collection, use, and disclosure, is efficient, adequate, and appropriate for personal data protection.

A policy has been established to participate in the declaration of intent to combat corruption ( Anti-Corruption) with Thai Private Sector Collective Action Against Corruption (CAC) project <0RaVwIRGx7Sl_space>

In the year 2025 The company declared its intention to combat corruption on January 13, 2025 with the goal of submitting for certification from the CAC Committee within 18 months from the date of the declaration of intent. The company has continuously developed and reviewed relevant policies, measures, and control processes to comply with CAC principles and guidelines.
2. Risk Assessment

In 2025, the Board of Directors approved the company's business risk management plan, prepared by the Risk Management Working Group. This plan involves assessing both internal and external factors that impact the company's strategy and business operations. The components of risk management are consistent with the generally accepted COSO-ERM framework and principles, which include considering (1) Governance and Culture, (2) Strategy and Objective-Setting, (3) Performance (Risk Management), (4) Review and Revision, and (5) Information, Communication, and Reporting. The company considers risks based on opportunities and potential impacts in various areas, such as Strategic Risk, Operational Risk, Financial Risk, and Compliance Risk. It also includes managing Corruption Risk in line with the Thai Private Sector Collective Action Against Corruption (CAC) project. The company's risk assessment process includes identifying, assessing severity, prioritizing, and responding to risks, by establishing control guidelines to prevent or reduce risks to an acceptable level. The company has reviewed its risk management plan through meetings.

Executive Committee, Audit Committee, and Board of Directors to maintain capabilities and build sustainability for the organization.

3. Control Activities

The company has adequate and appropriate internal controls for each key activity. For each key activity, necessary control guidelines are established in the form of important policies, as presented in the control environment components, regulations, rules, orders, operational procedure manuals, and work manuals, which clearly specify the necessary practices for each activity. An Audit Committee has been appointed as a crucial tool for the Board of Directors in overseeing operations. This Audit Committee performs its duties within the scope of authority and responsibilities assigned by the Board of Directors and reports to the Board of Directors if it finds any activity lacking adequate and appropriate internal controls.
4. Information and Communication

The company possesses information related to operations, financial and operational reporting, compliance with various policies and procedures, as well as information obtained from external sources. This information is communicated to management and internal users in a format that provides recipients with sufficient data to perform their duties and make effective decisions. The company's information and communication are appropriate.

5. Monitoring Activities

The company has monitoring processes that support the achievement of business objectives and the effectiveness of adequate internal controls, including ongoing monitoring and internal audit's assessment of internal controls. Additionally, in the year 2025 The company held a total of Board of Directors meetings 7 times. The Audit Committee meetings totaled 9 times. The Nomination and Remuneration Committee meetings

Total compensation 6 times. The Executive Committee meetings totaled 13 times, and the management regularly holds meetings to review and monitor operational performance to achieve the set goals.

5.1 Adequacy and Appropriateness of the Company's Control System

The internal auditor is responsible for auditing operations, evaluating internal controls, and reporting audit findings to the management and the company's Audit Committee. If any procedure or control is identified as a weakness, the management will consider and implement control measures to systematically and continuously resolve the issue.

The audited units received recommendations to rectify operations or to enhance control measures. The internal auditor will monitor and evaluate, as well as regularly report the results to the management and the company's Audit Committee.

5.2 The Audit Committee reported to the Board of Directors that the Audit Committee had considered the internal auditor's report and the report on the adequacy assessment of the company's internal control system in accordance with the guidelines of the Securities and Exchange Commission. It was of the opinion that the company's overall internal control system had no material deficiencies.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)000

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Honor Audit and Advisory Co., Ltd., an external and independent company, has been appointed as the Company's internal auditor, with Ms. Piyamas Ruangsangrob serving as the Head of Internal Audit. The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications, educational background, and work experience of Ms. Piyamas Ruangsangrob. It was found that she possesses experience in internal audit and accounting audit operations within the Company, and also has a thorough understanding of the Company's activities and operations. Furthermore, she has suitable qualifications and work history, and has continuously attended training courses related to internal system auditing. Based on its consideration, the Audit Committee believes that Ms. Piyamas Ruangsangrob is well-qualified to hold the position of Head of Internal Audit, as she can perform her duties independently and efficiently, which is in accordance with professional standards.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

To ensure efficient operations and compliance with international standards, the Company has engaged Honor Audit and Advisory Co., Ltd., an external and independent firm, as its internal auditor. Ms. Piyamart Ruangsangrob serves as the Head of Internal Audit for the Company. The Audit Committee has reviewed her qualifications, educational background, and work experience and is of the opinion that the proposed individual possesses experience in internal audit and accounting audit within the Company, understands the Company's activities and operations, and has suitable qualifications, work history, and training records in relevant courses to perform the internal audit function for the Company independently and effectively.
The approval, appointment, transfer, or termination of the company's internal auditor must be approved by the Audit Committee.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Eastern Star Resort Company LimitedJuristic PersonGolf Course

Subsidiary company

2025-12-31T00:00
Eastern Star Laisun New World Company LimitedJuristic PersonReal Estate Development

Subsidiary company

2025-12-31T00:00
The House Management Company LimitedJuristic PersonManagement and Administration of

Subsidiary

2025-12-31T00:00
Eastern Star Property Company LimitedJuristic PersonReal Estate Development

Subsidiary company

2025-12-31T00:00
Bangkok Television and Radio Company LimitedJuristic PersonAccepting television advertisements

Direct and indirect shareholders, with some executives also participating.

2025-12-31T00:00
Media Studio Company LimitedJuristic PersonEngage in the business of producing television dramas, television programs, and radio programs.

Direct and indirect shareholders, and some executives participating jointly.

2025-12-31T00:00
BBTV Equity Company LimitedJuristic PersonLeasing of office space and advertising airtime

Direct and indirect shareholders and some executives in common

2025-12-31T00:00
Ploenchit Human Resource Solution Company LimitedJuristic PersonTo operate a domestic job placement business.

Direct and indirect shareholders, and some executives are jointly involved.

2025-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
30.0 · Necessity: Used as working capital for business operations · Description: Loan amount of 40 million Baht. Repayment period upon demand, divided into 3, 6, and 9 months. No collateral. Interest rate: the lowest rate of promissory notes received by ESTAR at that time, minus 0.50%. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loan · Audit committee opinion: Acknowledged and approved the connected transaction between Eastern Star Real Estate Public Company Limited (ESTAR) for the purpose of obtaining a loan from Eastern Star Resort Company Limited. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.12 · Necessity: Used as working capital for business operations · Description: Interest rate 2% · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Accrued Interest · Audit committee opinion: Acknowledged and approved the connected transaction between Eastern Star Real Estate Public Company Limited (ESTAR) for the purpose of obtaining a loan from Eastern Star Resort Company Limited. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 1.0 · Necessity: The company manages and maintains the common areas of the project, utility systems, and various facilities used by its subsidiaries in their business operations. The collection of such common area service fees is intended to compensate for actual expenses incurred in management, maintenance, and utilities, which directly benefits the operations of the subsidiaries. · Description: Service rates are determined based on actual costs incurred and allocated proportionally to the utilized area or other appropriate criteria. This constitutes normal commercial terms and does not differ from the rates charged to other space users. · As of yesteryear: 1.0 · Nature of transaction: Central Management Service Fee Revenue · Audit committee opinion: Approve · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 4.0 · Necessity: The company manages and maintains the common areas of the project, utility systems, and various facilities used by its subsidiaries in their business operations. The collection of such common area service fees is intended to compensate for actual expenses incurred in management, maintenance, and utilities, which directly benefits the operations of the subsidiaries. · Description: Service rates are determined based on actual costs incurred and allocated proportionally to the utilized area or other appropriate criteria. This constitutes normal commercial terms and does not differ from the rates charged to other space users. · As of yesteryear: 4.0 · Nature of transaction: Other income (Service income - Electricity) · Audit committee opinion: Approve · 0.41 · Necessity: The company manages and maintains the common areas of the project, utility systems, and various facilities used by its subsidiaries in their business operations. The collection of such common area service fees is intended to compensate for actual expenses incurred in management, maintenance, and utilities, which directly benefits the operations of the subsidiaries. · Description: Service rates are determined based on actual costs incurred and allocated proportionally to the utilized area or other appropriate criteria. This constitutes normal commercial terms and does not differ from the rates charged to other space users. · As of yesteryear: 0.39 · Nature of transaction: Accounts Receivable · Audit committee opinion: Approve
375.0 · Necessity: For working capital within the company and for land acquisition. · Description: Loan facility details: Secured long-term loan in the amount of 375,000,000 Baht, with an interest rate for the first 6 months from the date the borrower receives the loan. · As of yesteryear: 375.0 · Nature of transaction: Long-term loan · Audit committee opinion: It is of the opinion that entering into the aforementioned transaction is reasonable and beneficial to the Company in enhancing liquidity for business operations and supporting investment in land acquisition for future business expansion, with borrowing terms superior to those offered by financial institutions. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 3.72 · Necessity: For working capital within the company and for land acquisition. · Description: A fixed interest rate of 3.50% per annum will be applied, with subsequent adjustments every 6 months at a fixed rate. This rate will be referenced to Krungsri Ayudhya Bank Public Company Limited's (BAY's) Minimum Loan Rate (MLR) for prime customers for term loans at that time, minus 3.78% per annum. The loan period and collateral are from September 23, 2024, to September 30, 2027, with land having a net book value of 537,320,000 Baht as of June 30, 2024. Interest payments are due every 6 months. · As of yesteryear: 4.53 · Nature of transaction: Accrued Interest · Audit committee opinion: It is of the opinion that entering into such a transaction is reasonable and beneficial to the Company, as it enhances liquidity for business operations and supports investments in land acquisition for future business expansion, with borrowing terms more favorable than those offered by financial institutions. · 12.0 · Necessity: For working capital within the company and for land acquisition. · Description: A fixed interest rate of 3.50% per annum will be applied, with subsequent adjustments every 6 months at a fixed rate, referenced to the then prevailing Minimum Loan Rate (MLR) for prime corporate customers of Bank of Ayudhya Public Company Limited (BAY’s MLR) minus 3.78% per annum. Loan Period: From September 23, 2024, to September 30, 2027. Collateral: Land with a net book value of 537,320,000 Baht as of June 30, 2024. Interest Payment: Every 6 months. · As of yesteryear: 5.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest Expense · Audit committee opinion: It is of the opinion that entering into such a transaction is reasonable and beneficial to the Company, as it enhances liquidity for business operations and supports land acquisition for future business expansion, with borrowing terms that are more favorable than those offered by financial institutions.
9.0 · Necessity: Headquarters location · Description: The rental price is at market rate, as it is the same price offered by Ploenchit Tower to other customers. The rental fee is slightly lower than that of neighboring buildings due to the building's older age. · As of yesteryear: 7.0 · Nature of transaction: Building rental and service charges paid · Audit committee opinion: The resolution of the Executive Board Meeting No. 11/2566 (October 30, 2023) approved the renewal of the lease agreement for the Phloen Chit office (Phloen Chit Tower) for a period of 3 years, from October 1, 2023, to September 30, 2026. This property lease transaction falls under the definition of a "connected transaction" because BBTV Equity Co., Ltd., which owns and leases the property, is a major shareholder of the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 1.71 · Necessity: Headquarters location · Description: The rental price is at market rate, as it is the same price offered by Ploenchit Tower to other customers. The rental fee is slightly lower than that of neighboring buildings due to the building's older age. · As of yesteryear: 1.71 · Nature of transaction: Security Deposit Debtor · Audit committee opinion: The resolution of the Executive Board Meeting No. 11/2566 (October 30, 2023) approved the renewal of the lease agreement for the Phloen Chit office (Phloen Chit Tower building) for a period of 3 years, from October 1, 2023, to September 30, 2026. This real estate lease transaction meets the criteria for a "connected transaction" because BBTV Equity Company Limited, which owns and leases the real estate, is a major shareholder of the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
2.03 · Necessity: The Company has advanced certain expenses on behalf of Eastern Star Lizun New World Co., Ltd., which are directly related to the business operations of Eastern Star Lizun New World Co., Ltd., to facilitate management flexibility and ensure continuous operations. These items are expenses for which Eastern Star Lizun New World Co., Ltd. is liable, and the Company has recorded them as receivables for full reimbursement. · Description: Such advance payments are based on actual value incurred, with no additional charges or special conditions, and require Eastern Star Lyson New World Co., Ltd. to repay within the agreed period, which are normal trade terms for the group of companies, do not result in any transfer of benefits, and are for the benefit of the group's management. · As of yesteryear: 1.9 · Nature of transaction: Other Current Receivables · Audit committee opinion: Approve · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.67 · Necessity: The company has engaged The House Management Co., Ltd. to manage the project, which ensures efficient project operations in accordance with established plans, budget, and standards, thereby benefiting the company and its shareholders as a whole. · Description: Project management fees are determined based on the scope of work and appropriate rates, comparable to market rates or similar service providers. Payment terms are set according to normal commercial practices. Outstanding balances at the end of the period are in accordance with the agreed credit term and do not constitute special benefits to the contracting parties. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Current Creditors · Audit committee opinion: Approve · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Company and its subsidiaries do not have a policy of entering into connected transactions. However, if it is necessary to achieve the utmost benefit for the Company, the Company will carefully consider the reasonableness, and the consideration for entering into connected transactions will be at prices or conditions that are not different from those with third parties. Furthermore, the Company will proceed according to the procedures stipulated in the regulations or announcements of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Stock Exchange of Thailand regarding the criteria, methods, and disclosure of connected transactions of listed companies, as well as strictly adhere to legal rules or regulations, and prioritize the Company's best interests. In addition, the Audit Committee will monitor and review the Company's intercompany transactions to ensure compliance with relevant regulations.

Contents